There has been many a time when I needed to bring a last minute contribution to a potluck party. These sugar-free peanut butter cups will make you the hit of the night and no one will ever know they took you 20 minutes to make, basically the time it takes me to pick out an outfit. 

Try for yourself and you'll see. Now, I must warn you they are very rich so you'll most definitely need some water or milk to go with them. They can also melt if you let them sit out, but that's usually not an issue.

Not only is this a quick recipe, but it's an easy cleanup. One bowl, a cupcake tray, and some measuring cups in the dishwasher and you're done. Yes, it's that simple.  Shhhhh, don't let on that they're sugar-free, they might go faster than you think.

Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cups

  • Prep Time:15 mins
  • Cook Time:0
  • Total Time:15 mins
  • Servings:6
  • Easy


  • 4 tablespoons melted coconut oil
  • 1/2 cup peanut butter
  • 1/4 cup cocoa powder
  • 1-2 teaspoons stevia extract
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1/2 scoop protein powder
milk chocolate, sweetmeat, cake, cream, milk, goody, sweet, candy, chocolate
Annalee Flaherty
  • Step 1

    Add all ingredients into a bowl and mix.

    Gif by: Annalee Flaherty
  • Step 2

    Pour mixture evenly into a cupcake tin.

    Gif by: Annalee Flaherty
  • Step 3

    Freeze for 15-20 minutes

    Gif by: Annalee Flaherty
  • Step 4


    Gif by: Annalee Flaherty