Spoon University Logo
FullSizeRender
FullSizeRender
Reviews

An In-depth Guide to Madison’s Donut Situation

This article is written by a student writer from the Spoon University at Wisconsin chapter.

A donut is one food in this world that is so simple, and yet is loved by so many. It is a puff of dough with a sugary topping that can change someone’s mood in an instant. Aside from mainstream brands such as Dunkin’ Donuts or Krispy Kreme, the donuts of Madison in smaller shops are also worthy of some face time. 

Greenbush Bakery 

late night doughnut cream
Brandon Fishman

Greenbush Bakery is known to be the best donut place in Madison, in my humble opinion. Greenbush is a Jewish bakery that makes donuts with an aroma that can be smelled from across the street.

Cake Donut (also known as an Old Fashioned Donut)

My personal favorite is the cake donut. It is an old fashioned donut with a density that retains the cake-taste and texture. It is slightly more dense then your stereotypical donut, dripping with glaze and adding to the sugary happiness you’ll feel while eating it.

Also from Greenish Bakery, the Blueberry Glazed Donut has a structure that resembles the cake donut, with a slight, yet not overwhelming, hint of blueberry mixed in with the sweet glaze coating.

Dough Baby

Dough baby is a newer bakery, but equally as impressive. The shop is right on State Street, and is easily accessible for students. They sell a variety of treats, as well as a few mouthwatering donut flavors.

Key Lime Pie Donut 

One of the most popular flavors is a Key Lime Pie Donut. It is complete with a lime curd-esque filling that oozes out with every bite. Complete with a graham cracker crumble topping, it gives this donut last touch needed to make the eater feel as if they are floating on a cloud of key lime pie straight from the Florida Keys.  

Cream Cheese Cake Donut

Donut
Emily Taub

The cream cheese cake donut, also from Dough Baby, is phenomenal as well. It is topped with vanilla frosting and rainbow dot sprinkles. Its best aspect is the unique taste of the dough itself. It isn’t too sweet because of the hint of cream cheese. 

Bassett Street Brunch Club

Yet another fantastic place that serves donuts is Bassett Street Brunch Club. It is known for its brunch and a tasty donut as a touch of sweetness to finish off the meal.

Chocolate Hazelnut Donut

One of the regular donuts served is the chocolate hazelnut. It is a plain donut topped with melty chocolate frosting and crushed hazelnuts. Taking a bite is like eating deconstructed Nutella. The hazelnuts give this airy donut the perfect amount of solid crunch to even out the ratio of soft to hard. These donuts are not as moist as others, therefore they go perfectly with a glass of milk.

Hurts Donut Company

Donut candy bar cookie
Hannah Skriloff

Hurts Donut Company is an unbelievably unique donut shop that is known to be open 25/7 (yes, they claim that they’re open 25 hours a day!).  Although it is based in Middleton, it’s an easy Uber ride away so we’re gonna role with it.  Unlike other Madison donut shops, they have incredibly original and diverse flavors that can’t be found anywhere else.  

Hurts’ Variety of Flavors 

Donut cake chocolate
Brandon Fishman

Hurts makes a donut that plays off of Sesame Street’s Cookie Monster, a slew of donuts topped with sugary cereals, and, best of all, the Slim Shady: a white donut covered with mini M&M’s. Overall, Hurts is sort of a hole-in-the-wall kind of place, but donut forget to check it out!

All of these donut shops are part of the unique aspects of Madison; they are what makes this city so sweet! The donuts of Madison are a key characteristic of this area, and no one should die without trying one.  

Spoon University Placeholder Avatar
Emily Taub

Wisconsin '19

All my life I have always been extremely fascinated about food, between cooking, baking, gardening, going to farmer’s markets, buying organic foods, trying new foods, etc.  I am so excited to be writing about the different foods that I have encountered, because what better than to write about something that you love!