Spoon University Logo
Baker Katherine Healthy Cookie Butter Final
Baker Katherine Healthy Cookie Butter Final
Recipes

How to Make Healthier Cookie Butter at Home

Cookie butter. AKA crack butter.

It’s certainly a delicious treat and makes a wonderful accompaniment to toast, fruit, ice cream, and more.

But there are times when maybe you wanna eat something a little healthier, or want to enjoy something that tastes a little bit less junky. Or maybe you’re the kinda person who is into DIYs. Whatever your reason, you should certainly give this healthier cookie butter recipe a try.

Sweet and spicy like the OG, this homemade cookie butter is just as addictive as store bought, but contains less hydrogenated oils, sugar, artificial ingredients and preservatives. Made with sunflower seed butter or sunflower seeds, it’s rich with healthful polyunsaturated fatty acids.

Now you can take spoonfuls to the face in the name of health.

Healthy Homemade Cookie Butter

Difficulty:BeginnerPrep time: 10 minutesCook time: minutesTotal time: 10 minutesServings:10 servings

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Photo by Katherine Baker

    If using sunflower seeds, pulse seeds in food processor or blender until a smooth paste/nut butter consistency is reached.

  2. Photo by Katherine Baker

    Add sunflower seed butter, brown sugar, cinnamon, and spices into a bowl. Mix well.

  3. Photo by Katherine Baker

    Enjoy on toast, fruit, oatmeal, or ice cream. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator.

Katherine has been involved with Spoon since the early days of the NYU chapter. She continued to write for Spoon while earning her master's degree in human nutrition at Columbia University and authored the Spoon Guide to Healthier 2016. Katherine likes to avoid wearing real pants, hanging out with her rescue pup Millie, drinking iced coffee in all 4 seasons, and baking vegan treats (yes, Baker is her last name). Katherine is now a student at Columbia Mailman School of Public Health and learns about how climate change impacts human health and nutrition (#school5ever). Hit her up on Insta (@katherinebaker4) and kbaked.com for more #relatablecontent.