We all remember the excitement of opening up your lunch bag to that pocket of goodness that is an Uncrushable (or being of jealous of those who did). Well, we're bringing that excitement to a kitchen near you with these DIY Uncrustables that are so easy to make (and customize), even your average cooking dumb college kid can handle it. 

DIY Uncrustables

  • Prep Time:10 mins
  • Cook Time:0
  • Total Time:10 mins
  • Servings:10
  • Easy


  • 20 slices Wonder bread
  • 10 tablespoons peanut butter
  • 10 tablespoons grape jelly
  • 10 tablespoons Nutella
  • 2 bananas
cream, strawberry, chocolate
Photo by Alex Frank
  • Step 1

    Roll bread out so it becomes flattened and thin.

    GIF by Alex Frank
  • Step 2

    Using cookie cutter to cut crusts off bread and into round pieces.

    GIF by Alex Frank
  • Step 3

    Spread peanut butter and jelly onto slices.

    GIF by Alex Frank
  • Step 4

    Repeat with fillings of your choice.

    GIF by Alex Frank
  • Step 5

    Using soft side of cookie cutter and press down on rounds to seal sides. Flip and repeat.

    GIF by Alex Frank
  • Step 6

    Dig in.

    GIF by Alex Frank