Spoon University Logo
Lifestyle

I Asked 30 College Students About Their Thanksgiving Memories — Their Answers Were About More Than Just The Food

Taking a bite of your favorite dish brings you back in time to a place where you feel safe and warm. For me, Thanksgiving is all about my grandma’s turkey and how she makes sure that it’s nice and juicy because she knows I love it. I have no idea what she seasons her turkey with, but just one bite has me wanting to hoard the whole bird to myself. Drizzling it in her warm gravy makes it so much more delicious. As the holiday approaches, I can feel myself salivating in anticipation of having her turkey, wondering how much I can fit into a storage container to take home with me before someone notices. But, why do we associate food with memories? And why is the connection between Thanksgiving food and memories particularly so powerful?

To explore that connection, I interviewed 31 college students, including friends and classmates, asking them to name their top three favorite Thanksgiving dishes and their favorite memory associated with the holiday. Their answers revealed more than a list of popular foods. From the magic of a mother’s baked mac and cheese to accidentally being forgotten in the basement while the rest of the family ate, the conversations I had with these students offered a glimpse into the traditions and moments that make each family’s Thanksgiving unique.

Many of the students I interviewed gave me similar answers when asked about their favorite Thanksgiving day foods. Fourteen students said that mashed potatoes are their favorite food on their table at Thanksgiving. 

“I make sure I get mashed potatoes on my plate before everyone else,” Raegan Braley, a junior college student from Connecticut, told me. “I used to hate mashed potatoes growing up, and then the one Thanksgiving that I suddenly was like, ooh, mashed potatoes taste good, I was assigned to be a babysitter at the children’s table. And so, I was actually unable to actually enjoy them because I was so busy dealing with misbehaving children.” 

Mac and cheese came in second place with 12 students saying that it was their favorite dish. Many mentioned that their family makes mac and cheese pie, also known as baked mac and cheese, saying that they prefer it baked with a crunchy top and creamy inside. 

“Mac and cheese is literally magical.” Julissa Yepez, a junior at John Jay College, said. “I love cooking with my mom. She makes the main dishes beside me, giving me tips and guidance as I make my side.”

Sweet potatoes and candied yams are nine students’ absolute favorite. Though these are very different dishes, I noticed that many students were using the names interchangeably. 

Sweet potato, also known as sweet potato casserole, is mashed or sliced sweet potatoes with a crunchy, sugary top and melted marshmallow covering the bright orange goodness. Candied yams are diced or sliced yams or sweet potatoes glazed in a mixture of butter, sugar, and cinnamon. 

Sweet potato casserole just so happens to be my favorite dish. I make it every year for Thanksgiving, along with cornbread, both of which have become my signature dish. When I was younger, my mother always bought the sweet potato casserole and cornbread from Boston Market, but when the one by our house closed, I learned to make it. To this day, everyone asks me if I’m bringing the sweet potato casserole. 

Other students shared with me their favorite cultural dishes which appear on their Thanksgiving tables year after year.

Speaking with students from different cultural backgrounds revealed how much Thanksgiving dinner tables can differ between families. Some of these non-traditional foods include Nigerian food such as pepper soup, jollof rice, and oxtail. Some of the Hispanic students I’d asked mentioned that they have rice and beans on their tables along with Pernil (Spanish roast pork) and fried plantain. 

“Pernil, rice, and beans taste delicious together,” Daniel Damas Hernandez, a student at Hunter College in New York City, told me. “It’s a classic Hispanic dish that we eat mainly on holidays and it reminds me of home.” 

As a Puerto Rican myself, I agree with this. My family usually eats Pernil on Christmas, but during every big feast, we almost always have rice and beans or yellow rice on the table. 

Incorporating cultural dishes with this traditional American holiday feast, helps many immigrant families feel like they’re back home. Cultural food like these bring forth memories which are tied to their past, whether it be their homeland or simply the food their immigrant parents grew up cooking for them. 

Whether it’s a plate of mashed potatoes, homemade mac and cheese, or a family recipe passed down through generations, every Thanksgiving table has its own story. The numbers may reveal which dishes are most popular, but the memories behind them reveal why those dishes matter. Long after the leftovers are gone and years after that day, those moments spent cooking, eating, and laughing with loved ones are what remain.

My name is Mya Pacheco and I am currently a junior at Hofstra University in Long Island, New York. As an intern for the National Writers Program at Spoon University, I will be writing articles about food trends and creating content to inform readers nationwide.

I have written news articles about events on my college campus, such as articles for campus art exhibits and club events, as well as, some issues students have been going through on campus. This summer, I completed an internship for The Child Center of New York, where I taught high schoolers about DOE school policies and work readiness. I also have a personal blog where I publish some of my school papers as well as fictional stories which I've written. (https://www.thevelvetarchive.online/)

In my free time, I enjoy writing fictional short stories, reading romance books, and painting landscapes. I am a lover of history, art and music. I am an old soul when it comes to fashion and music, loving the 1970s and 80s the most. I am a huge foodie, who loves to cook and bake on weekends. I developed my own chocolate chip cookie recipe which my family begs me for during the Christmas season even though I keep it secret. I love Marvel movies and my favorite TV show is Interview with the Vampire(2022).