Although all batches may look the same, each type of brownie has its own unique flavor, texture, and level of “gooeyness” depending on the box it comes in. Though the debate of fudgy vs cakey brownies will likely never be settled, everyone can agree that certain store-bought brownie mixes are better than others. I made it my mission to come up with a list of the 10 best brownie mixes at the grocery store based on the flavor and texture of the final product so you know which to purchase on your next shopping trip. Here are the best brownie mixes at the grocery store, ranked from best to worst.
1. Duncan Hines Milk Chocolate Brownie Mix
These never fail to impress at parties and get togethers. It’s a favorite of many, myself included. The ooey, gooey center melts perfectly in your mouth. Although it’s not recommended for a low-cal diet, we’re all entitled to a brownie here and there.
2. Ghirardelli Double Chocolate Brownie Mix
Calling all chocolate lovers! This one is a total must-try. The box includes chocolate chips that melt right into the batch of brownies when cooked. It gives it that delicious, warm gooey center that we all love, without the feeling of them being raw.
3. Ghirardelli Chocolate Supreme Brownie Mix
These brownies are neither too fluffy nor too fudgy—they’re the perfect combination of both! They melt in your mouth and pair perfectly with ice cream when warm. They’re even touted as being better than brownies from scratch, and if that doesn’t prove to you how good they are, I don’t know what will.
4. Betty Crocker Original Supreme Brownie Mix
The OG brownie mix. This is probably the mix that you grew up on and that your mom still uses. It never fails and will always be a contender for the best brownie mix on my list. These brownies taste homemade and are called the “supermodel of brownies,” a title that few mixes have attained. The chewy texture is simply divine! Best of all, it’s made with Hershey’s chocolate, so you’re really getting the good stuff.
5. Pillsbury Fudge Supreme Brownie Mix
The chocolate chunks in this mix are extremely noticeable, which adds a whole other dimension to the otherwise run-of-the-mill brownie mix. Although not fudgy like some of the others on this list, these brownies have a really delicious, moist texture that makes them totally deserve a spot in the top 5!
#SpoonTip: The cheesecake swirl edition (pictured above) is just as delicious as the regular version.
6. Betty Crocker Fudge Brownie Mix
Although it doesn’t include a packet of fudge to enhance the fudginess, these brownies taste just like they do. They are naturally gooey and delicious and emulate what it means to be a “melt in your mouth” kind of dessert. Definitely not one you want to miss on this list.
7. King Arthur Flour Gluten-Free Brownie Mix
My GF friends, this one is for you. If you didn’t read the box, you wouldn’t even know that these are gluten-free. They’re basically just really really good brownies that happen to be gluten-free.
8. Duncan Hines Chewy Fudge Brownie Mix
Another classic. It’s nearly impossible to make a bad batch of these. They taste homemade, just like they’re fresh out of your grandmother’s oven and baked with love. What more can you really ask for? Although I wouldn’t recommend to those who enjoy a more cake-like brownie, I would definitely suggest these for anyone who likes wetter, fudgier brownies.
9. Trader Joe’s Gluten-Free Brownie Mix
Another one for my GF friends out there. Again, if you weren’t told that these are gluten-free, you wouldn’t know the difference. They taste just like regular brownies and have the same texture, which makes them a great treat for everyone.
10. Trader Joe’s Brownie Truffle Baking Mix
This cake-like mix is Trader Joe’s version of a brownie mix. Although they rank in at the bottom of my list of best brownie mixes, that in no way means that they’re not totally delicious. They reach all new levels of fudge and are super easy to make, which is always a plus in my book. The mix includes chocolate chips that melt into the brownies and make them reach ultimate gooeyness.
Brownies are a delicious treat and all of these are totally approved by me. Enjoy each of them with a scoop of cold ice cream and great company and it will make for the perfect treat. To make your boxed brownies even better, try out some of these brownie hacks or throw some yummy mix-ins into your batter.