Spoon University Logo
Screen Shot 2016 03 03 at 1.23.26 PM 1
Screen Shot 2016 03 03 at 1.23.26 PM 1
Reviews

The 24 Most Instagram-Worthy Desserts in NYC

This article is written by a student writer from the Spoon University at NYU chapter.

If you’re a true foodie, you understand the importance of making sure that your waitress sits you in a booth with good lighting at a restaurant, that the caramel sauce on your ice cream is dripping down your cone, and that the chocolate chips in your Levain Bakery cookie are melted and mushy.

New York is known for the Empire State Building and extra-cheesy pizza, sure, but it’s especially known for its dank (to put it simply) cupcakes, ice cream sandwiches and cheesecakes galore – important, right? More importantly, once it’s on your Instagram feed.

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Gif courtesy of giphy.com

1. Milkshakes from Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @chicasennewyork on Instagram

Worth the three-hour wait, since making your own won’t ever be as beautiful as the real deal.

2. Cereal Milk Ice Cream from Momofuku Milk Bar

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @nordstromrack on Instagram

Get the sprinkles for a guaranteed 100+ likes.

3. “Super Premium” Ice Cream Cones from Emack & Bolio’s

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @missladyfinger on Instagram

The (c)on(e)ly thing I need to survive my week. A quintessential NYC eats Insta.

4. Birthday Cake Sundae from Quality Eats

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @new_york_city on Instagram

Eat cake because it’s someone’s birthday somewhere. But if you’re really celebrating, make sure you do it with some free birthday food.

5. Waffle Ice Cream Cone from Wowfulls

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @wowfulls on Instagram

Can’t wait to get a wowfull of this. Make sure you tag your dank waffle pic with #spoonfeed.

6. S’mores Ice Cream Rolls from 10Below Ice Cream

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @10belowicecream on Instagram

I need s’more has never been so applicable. Just watching the ice cream be made is an experience in itself, you can imagine how magical the first bite is.

7. Glazed Mini Donuts with Sprinkles from Doughnuttery

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo by Sara Rukeyser

Just a little donut in a big world. Have no shame in holding up your mini donuts for the ultimate insta.

#SpoonTip: Head up to the Highline right above Chelsea Market for the ultimate @foodintheair insta.

8. Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies from Levain Bakery

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @rcorrera on Instagram

It’s not a trend if you’re not in on it. Dw, some fellow Spoonies taste tested Levain’s cookies and we all agree that the chocolate chip walnut is hands down #1.

9. Brioche Ice Cream Sandwiches from Genuine Superette

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @hungrybetches on Instagram

Not all heroes wear capes. Your ice cream sandwich doesn’t always have to be on a chocolate chip cookie, ya know.

10. Funfetti Cookie from Schmackery’s

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @hungrybetches on Instagram

Funfetti is what fairy princesses eat for breakfast.

11. JARS by Dani

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @sweetsandsunsets on Instagram

JARS by Dani: possibly the best thing that’s ever been created by mankind.

12. Mini Macarons from Baked by Melissa

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @unbuttoningpants on Instagram

If you’re celiac, have no fear. BBM has got gluten free goodies for you, too.

13. “The Ron Bennington” Cupcake from Molly’s Cupcakes

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @moodyfoodyadventures on Instagram

Let’s all take a minute to thank Harry Burnett Reese for this freakin’ brilliant combo.

14. Salty Pimp Cone from Big Gay Ice Cream Shop

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @biteclubnyc on Instagram

Just as pimpy as it sounds. Brace yourselves for the dulce de leche surprise underneath that crispy chocolate layer.

15. Frozen Hot Chocolate from Serendipity 3

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of yelp.com

Nothing more New York than this. Chocolate lovers unite.

16. Red Velvet Ice Cream Sandwich from Melt Bakery

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @imafooodie_ on Instagram

Like a red velvet cupcake, but better. Cool off on a hot day, or eat it in mid-January for the insta.

17. PB & J Donut from Dun-Well Donuts

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @foodloverheaven1 on Instagram

PB & J has never tasted so good. Who needs bread when we’ve got donuts?

18. Chocolate Banana Pudding from Magnolia Bakery

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @hungrybetches on Instagram

No words necessary. The photo does enough justice.

19. Any Cupcake from Sprinkles

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @lovelypepa on Instagram

Don’t forget to try the Cupcake ATM for a truly eye-opening experience.

20. Dark Chocolate Gelato Panini from M’o Il Gelato

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @kellroons on Instagram

Been dreaming about this since it first showed up on Insta.

21. Donut Ice Cream Sandwich from Holey Cream

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @foodporndaily1 on Instagram

Hol(e)y crap. The hype is so real.

22. White Chocolate Shelled Brownie from Bodega Negra

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of Bodega Negra

It’s a sensual experience.

23. “Hit Me” Chocolate Cake from Catch NYC

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @jonathancheban on Instagram

The name couldn’t be more appropriate.

24. Froyo from Culture An American Yogurt Company

Instagram-Worthy Desserts

Photo courtesy of @new_fork_city on Instagram

All for me, none fro you.

#Spoontip: Don’t forget to caption your food porn with hella funny food puns, tag #spoonfeed and tag @spoonuniversity for a feature.

Sara is a first-year writer and editor for Spoon Bucknell. She believes in all things pizza, and would willingly end any and every one of her relationships for donuts. She lives for hamburger spring rolls, quality food instas and cocktails that don't taste like alcohol.