Though Peanut Butter & Co.’s jars of delicious PB can be found in your local grocery store, from Gristedes to Target, located on Sullivan Street just a block behind NYU Law, Peanut Butter & Co. is also a quaint store perfect for lunch or a yummy snack between classes.

The Peanut Butter Sampler is a great way to try everything that this comfort food eatery has to offer, including inventive flavors like spicy peanut butter, chocolate and cinnamon raisin. The buttery spread is served with apple slices, celery, carrots, and Melba toast. The spicy peanut butter, called The Heat Is On, has a lot of peppers and spices in it that gives it a real unexpected but favorable kick.Photo by Becky Hughes

Photo by Becky Hughes

For a sweeter sandwich, try the Fluffernutter: spoonfuls of peanut butter matched with gooey Marshmallow Fluff.

If you prefer a more savory sandwich, order the Mighty Maple–maple peanut butter paired with strips of bacon–which makes for a filling and satisfying sandwich.

peanut butter

Photo by Becky Hughes

Peanut Butter & Co. also offers an array of other food options including traditional savory sandwiches and salads as well as desserts like cookies and sundaes. Before you leave, make sure to check out the store’s supply of peanut butter for purchase so you can enjoy the nutty goodness at home.


Address: 240 Sullivan St (bet Bleeker and West 3rd)
Hours of Operation: Mon-Thu: 11am to 9pm, Fri-Sat: 11am to 10pm, Sun: 11am to 9pm