Spoon University Logo
Lifestyle

Here’s What The Cast Of ‘The Secret Lives Of Mormon Wives’ Orders At Soda Shops

The surging popularity of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives has come with a great deal of attention on their signature beverages, sodas. As one mom from the show, Jessi Ngatikaura, explained, the variety of soda shops that fill Utah are known as “the Mormon bar.” With drinking alcohol and coffee being against The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, these women need a special drink to get them through the day. Each mom has a different flavor combination that really suits them, goes with their personality and gives them their beverage fix for the day.

Check out all of the Mormon moms unique soda combinations for your next trip to Swig.

Whitney Leavitt

@whitneyleavitt

I can’t believe we found the original swiggers 🥤 !!!!!! @Swig

♬ original sound – Whitney Leavitt

Leavitt goes full-on with the fruit flavors in her soda order. It starts out with sparkling water as the base, then she adds sugar-free vanilla, sugar-free peach, sugar-free pineapple, raspberry puree, and a dash of lime for freshness.

Demi Engemann

@rallymallyy

They’re supposed to have it on their menu but just in case they dont know what it is….. 🍋‍🟩🥥🍍🍦🥤@Swig ✨Sparking water, with SF coconut, vanilla, pineapple, raspberry & coconut cream! @secretlivesonhulu #swigorder #secretlivesonhulu #slomw #momtok #secretlivesofmormonswives #slc #utahcheck #sodashops #sodashop #swigdrinks #swigutah

♬ original sound – Mallory | sahm + rv living ⚡️

Demi Engemann starts her bev off with a whopping 44 ounces of sparkling water. This serves as the base of the drink called The Fighter. This flavorful drink contains water, sugar-free vanilla, sugar-free peach, sugar-free pineapple, fresh lime, and raspberry puree. From there, she mixes in a variety of additional sugar free syrups including coconut, vanilla, raspberry, and pineapple. With just these ingredients, you can imagine yourself laying out on the beach with a fruity, tropical drink in hand. To level this soda up, Engemann tops her soda off with coconut cream. In the words of Engemann herself, this bevvy is “chef’s kiss.”    

Layla Taylor & Miranda Hope

Layla Taylor and Miranda Hope keep their order a little more simple than Engemann. They both start with a water-based drink with strawberry puree. From there, they add sugar-free vanilla, sugar-free coconut, and coconut cream. The only difference the two have between their orders is Taylor removes the frozen strawbs.

Jessi Ngatikaura, Jen Affleck, & Taylor Frankie Paul

@von_delulu

Mormon Soda 🥤🥤🥤 Watch the ladies of Hulu The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Layla, Demi, and Jessie place their Swig order. #mormonsoda #soda #mormon #swig #weirdsodaflavors #hulu #mormons #utah

♬ original sound – Von Delulu

These three pretty much all order the same thing. When Ngatikaura, Affleck, or Paul strut into Swig, they likes to keep things simple. They have a taste for a drink called Texas Tab. Ngatikaura differs from the rest of the MomTok group slightly as she only indulges in a 32 ounce bev. This soda has a Dr. Pepper base with add-ins of vanilla syrup and coconut cream.

Mayci Neeley

While Neeley’s bev order was never shown on the show, in an interview with Cosmopolitan, she explained this was her go to after deciding to try the drink the person ahead of her in line chose. The bev called A Berry Bad Doctor begins with a Dr Pepper base and has additions of raspberry puree, coconut and vanilla syrup and some cream. 

Mikayla Matthews

Engemann and Matthews seem to have similar tastes when it comes to their sodas of choice. They both start their drinks off with a base of sparkling water. From there, they both opt for the sugar-free syrups. Matthews adds in sugar free raspberry, pineapple, coconut, and coconut cream. This bev comes out as a beautiful blush pink and a nice mix of tropical flavors.

These ladies love to enjoy a soda at any time during the day, whether they need a morning wake up call, midday pick me up, or a bev to get them through the night. On your next trip to Swig, or just at home, sip on one of these unique creations and enjoy. 

This article was previously updated on October 26, 2024.

Beth Shoop is a member of the Spoon University National Writers Program as well as a student at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. In her role at Spoon University, she researches, analyzes, and writes stories surrounding the latest food trends, content creators, and other breaking news in the food and drink world!

Beth is a rising senior majoring in journalism with minors in digital media analytics, sports communication, and leadership. Beyond Spoon University, Beth works as the editor-in-chief of Her Campus at UW–Madison, where she writes, edits, and publishes all lifestyle articles written by club members. Additionally, Beth has written for UW–Madison’s student newspaper, The Daily Cardinal, acted as the Communications Associate for the Wisconsin Union, and worked as the Vice President of Media for CHAARG, an all-female workout and wellness group at UW–Madison.

In her free time, Beth can be found going on walks around the stunning UW–Madison campus, taking classes at her local spinning studio, or grabbing coffee with friends. She loves ending her night with a few episodes of Modern Family, a Netflix dating show, or Dance Moms (it’s a must-watch for a Pittsburgh Native).