Even though One Tree Hill is almost a 14 year old show, it will always be a Netflix favorite. No matter how many times I watch, the characters of One Tree Hill still touch my heart. 

Recently, my roommate and I found ourselves huddled around my laptop for the 5 time screening of Episode 1 Season 1 and as the night went on, the hungrier we got. We decided to order Insomnia Cookies and with every bite of cookie, I was reminded of a OTH character. What two things to match better?

1. White Chocolate Macadamia — Karen Roe

A photo posted by Danni (@revenge_oth_greys) on

This is a cookie for old time sake and Karen is your classic, loving mother. White chocolate is often looked at as a lesser form of chocolate, but when given the chance, it can be satisfying. 

2. Chocolate Chunk — Nathan Scott

There is an undeniable sweetness to the classic boy next store, Nathan Scott. Nothing says hunky like this Tree Hill star basketball player and big chocolate chunks. America loves a good chocolate chip cookie, just like they love Nathan Scott. 

3. S'Mores — Peyton Sawyer 

Nothing has more layers than a s'mores cookie, except for Peyton Sawyer. She is smooth like chocolate, sticky like a marshmallow and has that perfect bite of crunch. She may have a lot going on but somehow she has it all balanced out.

4. Snickerdoodle — Haley James

Haley is just sweet enough but she has that little kick we all look for in the perfect treat. Like a Snickerdoodle, she gives comfort when we most need it. Haley has an undeniable flavor of her own, just like a sugary Snickerdoodle

5. M&M's — Brooke Davis

She is spunky, colorful, and full of life. Brooke loves to be the center of everything, just like M&M's do. No one can forget about M&M's and no one can forget about Brooke Davis either.

6. Oatmeal Raisin – Dan Scott

A photo posted by @forevertreehill23 on

As much as we want to love Dan at some points, it's just not going to happen. As much as we want to choose the healthier alternative of a cookie, it's also just not going to happen. 

7. Sugar — Lucas Scott

Nothing says sweet like a sugar cookie. Lucas is an old soul and is forever easy to love like a simple sugar cookie. I mean who doesn't have a soft spot for his sugary personality? The reliable sugar cookie will always be there to nurture your sweet tooth, as will Lucas.

To me, there is nothing better than Nathan Scott and a warm cookie. So next time you decide to watch this CW classic, I hope you find yourself matching the Tree Hill residents with your yummy choice of a showtime treat.