With Thanksgiving just around the corner, one of the most important things to get ready is the food. Thanksgiving is the food holiday, and there is nothing that better represents the occasion than the iconic dishes of this day. As kids, you would draw a hand turkey or a pumpkin to represent what some people know as the most American holiday there is. There is no way to talk about Thanksgiving, a tradition that developed from fall harvest feasts in different cultures, and not talk about the food that makes up this holiday.
We’re close enough to the day that it is time to start going out and buying what we need to prep, and planning out exactly what we need to cook. You’re probably thinking of going for a classic dish or side, something no one would look twice at. But, have you ever wondered why these dishes are classics? Every traditional Thanksgiving dish has an origin that you probably did not know, and this is your chance to find out exactly why we eat all of these meals on this special holiday.
Turkey
The oven-roasted turkey that you carve at the dinner table as a family is the image everyone’s mind goes to when thinking about Thanksgiving. In some people’s minds, there is no Thanksgiving without a turkey, and there are many theories as to why that is. It is often theorized that the modern Thanksgiving menu is based on the meal shared between the Pilgrim settlers and the Wampanoag people in the fall of 1621. However, there is no evidence of them having eaten turkey on this day .
The tradition actually seems to come from the abundance of wild turkeys at the beginning of modern American history. They were too available and did not really serve any purpose other than meat, so they became the meal of choice for bigger gatherings. Many even credit literature of the time for the inclusion of this iconic dish, with authors like Charles Dickens and Sarah Josepha Hale, who wrote about a Thanksgiving turkey at the head of the table, which then gave the idea of a collective holiday meal for all who celebrate.
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
An important fact about potatoes in relation to Thanksgiving is that the modern russet potato that we know now was not yet available in what is now Massachusetts in the early 1600s, so there is no way that they were served at the original Thanksgiving dinner. It was not until the 1800s, after being brought to America, that potato dishes became a staple at large gatherings because of their filling nature and delicious flavor. Mashed potatoes also serve the purpose of being prepared in advance, giving you more time to focus on the rest of the meal.
The inclusion of mashed potatoes, much like turkey, can also be attributed to Sarah Josepha Hale. In her novel Northwood, she wrote a chapter on what an ideal Thanksgiving meal would look like, and afterward went on to campaign arduously for Thanksgiving to be considered a national holiday, until it was approved by President Lincoln in 1863.
Gravy, however, might date back to the time of the first Thanksgiving meal, as it was customary to create a sauce using the leftover aromatics from the cooked meat to make the dish more flavorful. At first, it was merely the drippings in the pan after cooking a piece of meat, but it became an element that stands apart from the turkey and complements every aspect of the Thanksgiving meal as it is poured over everything and brings the flavors together.
Cranberry Sauce
Cranberries are regarded as one of the few truly American fruits not altered by European agriculture. They were used by Native Americans for food, medicine, and even as a natural dye for a long time. Cranberries are also harvested in the fall, and Thanksgiving dates back to a fall harvest festival that would have been celebrated hundreds of years ago, even before the British settled in America. It makes absolute sense that they should be included. The most popular presentation is the canned, jellied form that really makes it feel like Thanksgiving, the same for everyone.
Stuffing
Surprisingly, stuffing seems to be a dish that dates back even further than all of our others so far, going as far back as the Roman Empire, which had stuffed birds to enhance flavor and moistness in the meat. It was later used by itself as a side dish to accompany the main meal. For the stuffing, it is all about the aromatics: so many herbs and nuts native to the American land are essential for a great-tasting dish (and very flavorful turkey).
Green Bean Casserole
More obviously than the other dishes we’ve talked about so far, the green bean casserole does appear to have been manufactured specifically and intentionally for the traditional Thanksgiving meal. It was created in 1955 in Campbell’s Test Kitchen as an attempt to reflect the tastes of the time, made with cheaper ingredients that would be accessible to everyone. The recipe uses canned green beans and soup instead of fresh, often more expensive produce to make it uniform for all who would want to try it. It quickly became a nationwide sensation that is now a staple in many families’ Thanksgivings.
Pumpkin Pie
For dessert, there are few more common dishes than pumpkin pie. Just like cranberries, pumpkins have been native produce of North and Central America for a long time, and they were one of the first things brought back to Europe after the discovery of the Americas in the 16th century. Some early versions of pumpkin pie even used the shell of the gourd instead of a crust to serve the dish. The modern version, a custardy filling in a flaky crust, was adopted in the 19th century and curated into the ideal Thanksgiving dessert just in time for the holiday’s national recognition in the mid-century, creating yet another iconic image for the staple American Thanksgiving.